1,500 food jobs could be lost in Scotland after Brexit

Brexit could cost Scotland's food and drink sector £150M

Up to 1,500 food and drink industry jobs could be lost in Scotland after Brexit, which could cost the sector £150M, warn researchers.

The report, from the Fraser of Allander Institute, estimated that between 500 and 1,500 jobs would be lost in Scotland when the UK leaves the EU, even if the UK negotiated access to the EU’s 500M consumers. That would cost the industry at least £75M, which could reach up to £120M. The report said Scotland would fare better than the rest of the UK.

The report used three possible scenarios to predict the UK’s future after Brexit, including a Norway scenario (soft Brexit), Switzerland scenario and a World Trade Organisation (WTO) scenario (hard Brexit). The Norway scenario allowed the UK access to the Single Market, while the Switzerland model only allowed the UK partial access to the market. The hard Brexit scenario did not allow the UK access to the Single Market.

The researchers said Scotland would lose between £40M and £90M in a Switzerland-style deal, and would lose as much as £150M in a hard Brexit scenario.

‘GDP between 2% and 5% lower’

Fraser of Allander report – at a glance
  • Scotland to lose between 500 and 1,500 jobs in food and drink sector
  • Sector to lose as much as £150M post-Brexit
  • Between 30,000 and 80,000 job losses in total
  • Scotland would still fare better than the rest of the UK

Fraser of Allander Institute head of economic modelling Katerina Lisenkova told FoodManufacture.co.uk: “In our scenarios in the long term, the food and drink sector could potentially lose between 500 and 1,500 jobs. But there could be other jobs related to food and drink in adjacent sectors, such as in retail.”

The report said: “Brexit is predicted to have a negative impact on Scotland’s economy. Over the long-term, a reduced level of trade is expected to result in Scottish GDP [Gross Domestic Product] being between 2% and 5% lower than would otherwise be the case.

The food and drink manufacturing – Scotland’s largest export sector – was identified as needing particular attention.

“We recommend that focus is now given to sectors that have close trading links with the EU – such as food and drink and some manufacturing sectors – to fully understand the particular issues facing them on a product-by-product basis.”

Overall, Scotland could lose between 30,000 and 80,000 jobs in total across all sectors after Brexit, the researchers said. They added that the rest of the UK would have more job losses.

‘A grim picture of Scotland’

Scottish National Party’s Joan McAlpine MSP said: “This report paints a grim picture of Scotland’s economy 10 years after Brexit.

“Our committee has already found that maintaining access to the Single Market is key for business and industry in Scotland. If the UK government leads us into a ‘hard Brexit’, the evidence presented in this report indicates that there could be disastrous consequences for jobs, exports and production.”

Read the full report here.


Report Brexit scenarios:

Norway scenario (Soft Brexit)

  • Member of the European Economic Area (EEA)
  • Full access to Single Market (outside customs union and subject to ‘economic border’)
  • Financial contribution to EU
  • Free movement

Switzerland scenario

  • Member of the European Free Trade Association, but not EEA
  • Partial access to Single Market
  • Smaller financial contribution to EU
  • Free movement

WTO scenario (Hard Brexit)

  • World Trade Organisation rules for international trade
  • No obligation to apply EU laws
  • Some tariffs to trade with EU
  • Services trade restricted
  • No financial contribution to EU
  • No free movement
FoodManufactureJobs Set up a Job Alert

Related News

Brexit could have a big impact on food manufacturers

Brexit: top three challenges for food manufacturers

Business confidence has fallen since the Brexit vote

70% of food firms less confident since Brexit vote

Ian Wright urged manufacturers 'don't panic'

FDF boss urges ‘don’t panic’ over Brexit

BRC warned the price of wine and meat could rise after a hard Brexit

Meat and wine to become more expensive after Brexit: BRC

New evidence shows most Scots don't follow healthy eating recommendations

Scottish £250k funding aimed at improving food culture

GMB slammed Andrea Leadsom after it said she failed to answer questions on Brexit

Lack of Brexit plans a ‘huge threat’ to food industry

DWF's Dominic Watkins said businesses need more information about Brexit plans

Food firms can’t plan for Brexit until given more information

Joanne Denney-Finch said shoppers would be in control of prices

Retailing competition could reduce Brexit cost impacts

Brexit would offer food safety opportunities and risks

Food safety policy to be restructured post-Brexit

Scottish food and drink firms given £3M investment boost

Scottish government in £3M supply chain boost

Overseas investment in UK firms has been spurred by the falling pound

Overseas investors look to UK food sector

Brexit presented Britain’s biggest peacetime challenge, said Ian Wright

Brexit is ‘biggest problem in peacetime’: FDF boss

Forty-six jobs under threat at Addo Food Group's Spalding Bakery

Addo Food Group plans to cut nearly 50 jobs

‘The biggest question facing UK food and drink is what direction of travel the government will disclose for Brexit’ : Rick Pendrous

Food and drink sector squares up to Brexit challenges

Food and drink in Scotland could see a £750M boost if producers take on public-sector contracts, such as school dinners

Potential £750M boost to Scottish food industry

Fergus Ewing: Scotland is open for business and will continue working with colleagues across Europe

Brexit: ‘Scotland open for business’ with Europe

Scotland's food manufacturers expect the sector to boom

Scottish food and drink sector to create 14,000 jobs

Scotch whisky exports were on the rise for the first time in three years: SWA

Scotch whisky exports growth is first for three years

Food and drink manufacturers are coming to terms with the decisive vote for Brexit

It’s Brexit: UK votes to leave EU in historic decision

Brexit is set to change food buying habits, predicts Nielsen research

Brexit to change food buying habits: Nielsen

Francis Maude: ‘A good [corporation tax] benchmark for me is the Irish rate, which is 12.5%’

Corporation tax likely to be cut as Brexit proceeds

Here's what Brexit could mean for food and drink manufacturers

Brexit: what it means for food and drink manufacturers

Comments (1)

Alan Devine - 07 Oct 2016 | 03:05

Incorrect impression being given

The report predicts a lower level of future growth, thereby leading to fewer new jobs being created than would otherwise have been the case. It does not predict that existing jobs would be lost as your report implies. A subtle yet important distinction I think.

07-Oct-2016 at 15:05 GMT

Submit a comment

Your comment has been saved

Post a comment

Please note that any information that you supply is protected by our Privacy and Cookie Policy. Access to all documents and request for further information are available to all users at no costs, In order to provide you with this free service, William Reed Business Media SAS does share your information with companies that have content on this site. When you access a document or request further information from this site, your information maybe shared with the owners of that document or information.