Health and safety fines ‘could top £10M soon’

Health and safety fines 'could top £10M'

Health and safety fines in food manufacturing could soon reach more than £10M for a single offence, after a “seismic shift” in the size of penalties since the beginning of last year, according to DWF partner Dominic Watkins.

New guidelines for safety penalties – introduced from February 2016 – have raised the average fine for serious health and safety breaches to about £2M, Watkins told FoodManufacture.co.uk. Manufacturing fines could continue to rise, after a record-breaking £5M penalty on the owner of Alton Towers in September 2016, after a carriage collision on one of its roller coasters, he added.

“While the overall number of firms being fined has not changed that much, what has changed is the size of those fines,” Watkins said. “We are seeing a seismic shift in the level of fines being handed down.

‘A new average emerging’

“The current highest fine is £5M, but it is only a matter of time before fines top £10M. We are starting to see a new average emerging at around £2M for serious cases with both Bakkavor and Warburtons having received fines in this range. By contrast those cases probably would have attracted a fine no more than 20% of that number before.”

Watkins’ comments came after law firm BLM published its health and safety tracker in March. Food manufacturing penalties contributed just over £2M to UK manufacturing’s total pay-outs in 2016, which came to more than £12M.

The tracker showed McCain Foods received the largest penalty of £800,000 in May 2016, after a worker nearly lost an arm in an accident involving a conveyor (see the chart below for more information).

Two food manufacturers have been fined £2M this year already. Warburtons was ordered to pay out after a worker was hospitalised following a fall from a mixing machine. Bakkavor was fined after a worker died when plastic bales fell on top of him.



Sentencing guidelines changed last year with new legislation for health and safety, food hygiene and corporate manslaughter offences. Courts now consider culpability, seriousness and likelihood of harm, and the size of a business and its turnover when imposing fines.

BLM head of health and safety Helen Devery said: “The new sentencing guidelines send a strong message to all manufacturers big or small. It is people and business critical to ensure that safety processes and systems are a board level priority.

“The introduction of the risk of harm means that near misses will be reviewed and subject to potential prosecution, so this has been a game-changing 12 months for the industry. Robust and proactive audit processes, which interrogate and improve systems, will be seen as best practice and at the heart of this is a commitment to effective risk assessment and training across all parts of the business.”

Meanwhile, last week an Essex salad growing company was fined £120,000, after a worker was seriously injured by a chainsaw while felling trees.

Related News

Oban Fish Selling Co Ltd was fined £13,500 for the offences

Fish processor to pay £15,000 for hygiene offences

POE Ltd was ordered to pay after incorrectly labelling chicken heart and liver, and for unhygienically manufacturing food

Food firm told to pay £44k for food hygiene offences

The agency worker’s hand injury could have been avoided, said the HSE

Food polythene firm fined after agency worker injury

Freight firm Bryan Alexander was fined more than £40k for crush injuries

Crushed worker costs freight firm thousands

Warburtons was fined £2M after a work sustained live changing injuries after falling from a mixing machine

Warburtons fined £2M for worker’s fall

Two food packaging firms were fined for health and safety failings

Food packaging firms fined for safety failings

SCLA Ltd was fined £30,000 after a worker suffered 'life changing injuries' to their hand

Noodle firm fined for ‘life changing’ injuries

Salad firm Growing Green was fined £120,000 for health and safety failings

Salad firm fined £120k for worker’s serious injury

A butchery firm was fined £18k for hand lacerations

Hand lacerations cost butchery firm £18k

Related Products

See more related products

Submit a comment

Your comment has been saved

Post a comment

Please note that any information that you supply is protected by our Privacy and Cookie Policy. Access to all documents and request for further information are available to all users at no costs, In order to provide you with this free service, William Reed Business Media SAS does share your information with companies that have content on this site. When you access a document or request further information from this site, your information maybe shared with the owners of that document or information.