Brexit debate

Brexit backed by more smaller food firms

Smaller food and drink operators are more in favour of a Brexit than big manufacturers

Support for a Brexit in next month’s EU referendum is stronger among smaller food and drink operators, with many not expecting it to make a very big difference to their businesses, according to a new survey conducted by the publisher of this website.

The new research (see panel below) commissioned by William Reed, the publisher of FoodManufacture.co.uk and Food Manufacture, in conjunction with its market research arm Him!, has shown that many smaller food and drink businesses do not expect to be materially affected by a Brexit vote.

This finding will be music to the ears of the former environment secretary and ardent Brexit campaigner Owen Paterson, who will be speaking on the impact of a vote to leave the EU for regulation and innovation in UK food and farming at the Crop Protection Association’s (CPA’s) annual convention, which takes place next Thursday (May 12) in London.

Owen Paterson

Paterson will be joining Sir James Paice, another former food minister, Guy Smith, vice president of the National Farmers Union, and Professor Huw Jones, from Aberystwyth University, in a panel session chaired by Alastair Driver, political editor of Farmers Guardian, on the subject.

“Farming, more than any other sector, will be affected enormously by the outcome of June’s referendum and regulatory reform is a crucial aspect of the debate,” said CPA ceo Nick von Westenholz.

“Those urging us to remain in the EU must set out a clear path for improving the system in a reformed EU, and not simply argue that a UK outside the EU will nevertheless remain subject to the same burdensome regulations.

Von Westenholz added: “Similarly, those campaigning for Brexit need to set out the mechanism for establishing a post-EU regulatory system that will promote the competiveness and productivity of UK farmers. These issues involve important questions that farmers will want to know the answer to.”

Survey on EU membership

Of the 525 respondents to the William Reed survey (there were 561 respondents in total) to a question about their personal voting intentions, 39% planned to vote to leave. Against this finding, 37% believed leaving the EU could have disastrous consequences for their businesses and planned to vote to remain, with 21% still undecided.

While food and drink manufacturers were broadly supportive of the UK staying in the EU, with 52% convinced leaving would be bad for UK food and drink, foodservice operators – particularly small traders in the pub sector – lean towards a Brexit, with 46% planning to vote ‘out’.

This contrasts starkly with the views of the Food and Drink Federation, which came out strongly in favour of remaining in the EU (71%) following a recent survey of its food and drink manufacturing members earlier this year. It is also counter to the views of the majority of attendees at this year’s Food Manufacture Business Leaders’ Forum, held in London in January.

Among retailers and wholesalers, surveyed by Him!, the split is even, with 33% for a Brexit and 33% against from a professional point of view, though 43% plan to vote ‘leave’ in a personal capacity. However, this may reflect the fact that the numbers of responses from both the farming and retail sectors in the survey were not particularly high.

‘Security above commercial interests’

“Security comes above commercial interests, and closing our borders will go a long way to achieving this,” said one respondent when asked why they were backing Brexit despite business concerns.

“We need to make our own rules and trade deals,” added another pro-Brexit respondent.

Yet, many food and drink professionals remain deeply concerned at the potential impact of a UK exit. “If the vote is out, the changeover uncertainty will hamper investment and growth, potentially leading to stagnation for a period until new terms are established,” said one.

Most respondents (40%) warned food and drinks prices could rise outside the EU by an average of 2.4% with many citing a fluctuating exchange rate and changes to trade deals.

“The cost of goods imported by my wholesalers will probably rise, which means increasing costs for us and inflating prices to our customers,” said one retailer.

Other key areas of concern highlighted by the survey included uncertainty over employment, recruitment and trading relationships.

‘End of our business’

“An exit would be the end of our business,” said one baker. “The pound has already dropped in value at the mere thought of an exit, it will fall even more if we exit, which would make all our ingredients and packaging so expensive that we could not sell them in the UK any longer.”

Another meat supplier added: “The UK in the meat industry has had reputational issues to overcome and has been very successful post BSE. It does, however, have a long way to go still and needs the EU support. The UK is a small island versus the super leagues that are China and the US.”

 

William Reed Brexit survey highlights

Voting for a Brexit: 39%
Leaving EU would be disastrous: 37%
Product innovation would stay the same after Brexit: 46%
A net increase in prices of food and drink: 40%
Migrant workforce is not important: 64%
Seasonal workforce is not important: 74%
Labour force unaffected by Brexit: 64%
Migrant labour productivity same after Brexit: 50%
EU imports harder after Brexit (net view): 43%
EU exports harder after Brexit (net view): 47%
Non-EU imports would remain the same: 43%
Non-EU exports would be easier (net view): 25%
Brexit would reduce red tape: 50%
Brexit would make no difference to food safety: 65%
Brexit would make no difference to food crime: 45%
Brexit would free up UK on obesity/health policies: 58%
*Sample size: 525

Related News

Owen Paterson (left) and James Paice: opposite sides in Brexit debate

Former Tory food ministers slug it out over Brexit

Liz Truss urged food and drink business leaders to tell their staff about the benefits of EU membership

Firms ‘should tell staff about EU benefits’: Liz Truss

EU membership 'is vital' for the success of our food and drink sector: Sir Stuart Rose

EU ‘vital for food industry success’: Sir Stuart Rose

Boparan warns a Brexit would ‘decimate’ the British food industry

2 Sisters’ boss Ranjit Boparan warns against Brexit

Sir Stuart Rose, chairman of Britain Stronger in Europe

EU is ‘friend to food and drink’: Sir Stuart Rose

Summer salad prices are rising over fears of a Brexit

Brexit fears driving up food and drink prices

A vote to leave the EU will hit UK food manufacturing, according to our new survey

Brexit will ‘damage UK food manufacturing’: survey

Food manufacturers could face ‘severe’ consequences if Britons vote to leave the EU, warns a logistics provider

Brexit could have ‘severe’ trade impact on food firms

A Brexit vote would impact food and drink more than other sectors, warned Liz Truss

Food sector 'better off in the EU': Liz Truss

A vote to quit the EU could blight the British economy until 2020, claimed the new report

Food industry ‘blighted until 2020’ if Brexit wins vote

Which way will you vote? Vote in Food Manufacture's preview poll

EU referendum: and the result will be …

Twitter exploded today, with the food industry expressing its fears after the EU referendum

Food industry reacts to Brexit – in Tweets

Fergus Ewing: Scotland is open for business and will continue working with colleagues across Europe

Brexit: ‘Scotland open for business’ with Europe

A more integrated supply chain is needed post Brexit, argues Tsinopoulos

Brexit: food firms need integrated supply chains

Support: good food, farming and fishing policies must be central to any post-Brexit strategy

Brexit: 80 organisations call for food and farming support

The Brexit challenges will become more severe after six months

Brexit challenges will materialise after six months

Food and drink manufacturers were concerned about how Brexit would affect their business

What food and drink manufacturers worry about most

Provision Trade Federation director general Andrew Kuyk

Provision Trade Federation boss sets out his plans

Dark clouds ahead were predicted for British farmers by the NFU boss

Brexit will prove ‘messy and ugly’ for farmers

GMO production could become legal in the UK after Brexit

GMO law change will lead to glut of imports

Some food firms may be planning to quit the UK after the Brexit vote

Brexit could drive food firms offshore

Barrier-free access to the EU Single Market is vital: CBI

Barrier-free EU Single Market access is vital: CBI

‘The biggest question facing UK food and drink is what direction of travel the government will disclose for Brexit’ : Rick Pendrous

Food and drink sector squares up to Brexit challenges

Nearly one fifth of UK food and drink exports go to Ireland. © iStock

UK food industry calls for early Brexit deal with Ireland

iStock  ©

Higher prices and movement of manufacturing part of “huge” Brexit impact on food, predicts Rabobank

©iStock

British retail consortium releases ‘Brexit Tariff Roadmap’

Food and drink manufacturers voiced their concerns over the impact of Brexit on their businesses

Food Manufacture survey reveals Brexit fears

Brexit could spark a 'food industry crisis', warns the new report

Brexit could spark a ‘food factory crisis’

Brexit: Should we stay or should we go? The FDF is expected to decide its view today

Food and Drink Federation bosses in Brexit meeting

A new Scottish independence referendum would be triggered by a UK vote to quit the EU, said James Withers

Scottish food and drink manufacturers ‘fear Brexit’

Coveney said a plan b was not necessary at this moment should Britain leave the EU

Greencore considered Brexit, but not planning for it

Food prices 'would not rise' after a vote to quit the EU

Food prices ‘will not be affected by Brexit’

Welsh food products would be hit by Brexit, claims the FUW

Brexit: ‘dangerous step into unknown’, says union

Coveney: 'The more we've looked at Brexit, the clearer it is it would be bad'

Greencore boss warns against Brexit

Rick Pendrous, editor, Food Manufacture

Food industry bosses want UK to stay in EU

Comments (1)

howard scaife - 06 May 2016 | 11:06

brexit

We hear lots of anti brexit scare stories, However the remain campaign has not give even one little fact about the future if we remain on this bus which is heading in a direction we do not know or the cost. We do know that the EU proposes our armed forces come under EU control, we also know that Germany,France & Spain wish to have one rate of corporation tax in the EU and Mr Cameron's talks did not exclude us from this harmonisation 30% corporation tax will have a very negative impact on all UK business and lots more tax going to the EU. Security of our borders should be our no1 priority and we to decide who enters our country. No answers from Remain so Brexit is my vote for my families future.

06-May-2016 at 23:06 GMT

Submit a comment

Your comment has been saved

Post a comment

Please note that any information that you supply is protected by our Privacy and Cookie Policy. Access to all documents and request for further information are available to all users at no costs, In order to provide you with this free service, William Reed Business Media SAS does share your information with companies that have content on this site. When you access a document or request further information from this site, your information maybe shared with the owners of that document or information.